In Harry Potter, Dumbledore could have defeated Voldemort with dark magic. But why did he choose the moral path? We say it.
Albus Dumbledore barely skidded past the Dark Arts. (Source: Warner Bros. / Screenshot Netflix)
The “Harry Potter” films can be seen every week until Christmas: The weekly broadcast of the “Harry Potter” films on free TV begins again in late autumn. We list all the “Harry Potter” broadcast dates for you!
Albus Dumbledore is known in the “Harry Potter” universe not only as a powerful wizard, but also as a moral anchor. Many fans question why Dumbledore refused to use the dark arts to defeat Voldemort despite his superior power.
Why did Dumbledore deny dark magic?
Dumbledore would undoubtedly have had the power to defeat Voldemort with black magic. But he consciously decided against it. His decision stems from a fundamental lesson from his past: he knew how tempting and destructive power can be. His close, if brief, collaboration with Grindelwald had shown him where the pursuit of power could lead.
He saw how tempted he himself had been by the prospect of power and control, and realized that even the noblest goals do not justify the use of dark magic. In this sense, his refusal to use the dark arts was a way of keeping himself in check and maintaining his moral compass.
Dumbledore saw himself as the guardian of a line that could not be crossed, and this self-discipline made him not weaker, but in some ways even stronger than Voldemort. Voldemort trusted completely in the dark arts, while Dumbledore proved through his restraint that power lies not only in abilities but also in the control over them.
Why did Dumbledore allow death and suffering even though he was so powerful?
Dumbledore’s moral decision entailed a complex tragedy: he knew that his intervention might have prevented the suffering of others, especially Harry. But he was aware that his own actions would not provide a long-term solution.
Voldemort represented an ideology of oppression and obsession with power, and Dumbledore knew that simply defeating that ideology would not be enough. He wanted to get the wizarding world to rise up against Voldemort’s influence and saw Harry as a chance to do just that.
By sending Harry on this difficult journey, he allowed the world to stand up to evil and gave the community the opportunity to grow and take responsibility. This was his idea of the “greater good,” that humans themselves must ultimately reject evil rather than rely solely on the strength of an individual.
Every fan has to decide for themselves how noble it was of Dumbledore to put up with the Wizarding Wars just to be considered “good”. However, the wizard made many sacrifices for the greater good.
The balancing act between power and morality
If Dumbledore had used the dark arts, he could have prevented the suffering of many in the short term, but in doing so he would have violated his own moral boundaries. So he chose a path that would allow him to maintain his values and ideals, even if it meant not going down in history himself as “the one who overthrew Voldemort.” He wanted to be a role model for future generations and not the one who fought “evil with evil.”
{question}
{body}
There were {totalVotes} Votes cast
He knew that only through example and renunciation of dark power could true change be brought about in the world.
The “Harry Potter” films are currently broadcast weekly on free TV on Sat.1. We provide you with all the broadcast dates of the “Harry Potter” series! You can also watch the films streamed on RTL+ with a subscription.
Harry Potter quiz: How well do you know Hogwarts and Co?
(Those: tmdb.org)
In which well-known film does Snape actor Alan Rickman also play a shady character?
- » Tipp: The best VPN providers for more security and data protection
- » Buy balcony power plant: Comparison of the best solar systems
Don’t miss anything with this NETWORK WORLDNewsletter
Every Friday: The most informative and entertaining summary from the world of technology!
Table of Contents
