Does Star Trek really need a space CIA? Well-known sci-fi author faces “100 percent” against Section 31

Geralt of Sanctuary

Does Star Trek really need a space CIA? Well-known sci-fi author faces “100 percent” against Section 31

Author, CIA, faces, percent, SciFi, section, Space, Star, Trek, Wellknown

Star Trek; Section 31 is not easy and the award -winning leading actress Michelle Yeoh (Philippa Georgiou) cannot change that. Image source: Paramount Pictures
Star Trek; Section 31 is not easy and the award -winning leading actress Michelle Yeoh (Philippa Georgiou) cannot change that. Image source: Paramount Pictures

Star Trek; Section 31 is not easy and the award -winning leading actress Michelle Yeoh (Philippa Georgiou) cannot change that. Image source: Paramount Pictures

Star Trek: Section 31 is currently being torn up by critics and fans were also skeptical from the start.

Now even a former author of the Sci-Fi universe is moving with: Chad Quandt. He wrote the script for the Star Trek series Prodigy and can be the space CIA from Section 31 also win little.

He also contradicts the franchise boss Alex Kurtzman.

More to be against it is not possible

A week ago, a screenshot of a bluesky post was circulating on Reddit. In it, the former Star Trek screenwriter Chad Quandt is against Section 31.

Quandt's original post has now been removed and not even his bluesky account is currently available. You can see the Reddit Post (and what quandt says) here:

Recommended editorial content

At this point you will find an external content of Reddit that complements the article.
You can have it displayed with one click and hide it again.

I agree that I am displayed by Reddit.

Personal data can be transmitted to third -party platforms. More on this in our data protection declaration.

Link to Reddit content

Hey, I no longer have creative power at Star Trek, so that means nothing, but I am 100% against the head of the franchise Alex Kurtzman justifies a space CIA so that the federation can exist.

Quandt makes a direct reference to a statement by Alex Kurtzman. He recently made it clear that the vision of the Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry can only work if the federation has a good and bad side (via Trekmovie). Accordingly, the star fleet would no longer be pure utopia.

Ultimately, we want to say that the star fleet and the wonderful vision that Roddenberry had from this optimistic utopia can only exist if there are people who act in the shade so that the light exists.

And that's a yin and yang. You can't have one without the other.

The comments are eagerly discussed and many are Quandt's opinion. Here are a few examples:

  • “The funny thing is that Alex Kurtzman's opinion corresponds directly to the opinion of Section 31. But if you actually know something about Star Trek, then you know that section 31 are the bad guys and are absolutely not needed. « – User Loganolag
  • “Roddenberry used optimism as an allegorical means to tell stories that appeal to his contemporary audience, while Kurtzman chose exactly the opposite approach.” bitwarrior80
  • “We already have the star fleet secret service, why do we need a shady dark side?” jl_theprofessor
  • “› Kurtzman: »You can't have one without the other.‹ The spirit of Gene Roddenberry: ›Yes, you can! That is the point of the matter! '« – user Joncoqttentten

What is it about in Star Trek: Section 31?

Star Trek: In the trailer for Section 31, imperator Georgiou returns with an important task
Star Trek: In the trailer for Section 31, imperator Georgiou returns with an important task


Start video


1:52


Star Trek: In the trailer for Section 31, imperator Georgiou returns with an important task

Section 31 you can have been January 24, 2025 Watch on Paramount Plus. The film plays between Star Trek 6: The undiscovered country and Spaceship Enterprise: The next century.

In the new work, Philippa Georgiou (Michelle Yeoh) joins the secret espionage department »Section 31«. There she and her group get the task of making a weapon harmless that could destroy the entire universe.

A few days before the release of Section 31, the director Olatunde Osunsanmi (the fourth species, Star Trek: Short Treks) tried to calm the fans. Because many suspected that the new film could no longer do justice to the central Star Trek ideals such as peace, hope, optimism and diplomacy. You can find more about this in the article linked above.

Leave a Comment