Google and the industry demand its removal for violating the law

NinFan

Google and the industry demand its removal for violating the law

Demand, Google, industry, Internet, law, News and Updates, piracy, removal, streaming platforms, violating

The fight against piracy has strengthened in the last two years, especially regarding pirated IPTV to watch football and other live content like TV channels. These services allow users to tune in to legal content streams, usually at a much lower price than the official alternative. Football leagues have determined that this technology poses their biggest threat yet and have urged governments to implement swift measures, sometimes regardless of possible consequences.

The best example of this new policy is the Piracy Shield, the blocking system launched last year in Italy and which, in just a few months, has managed to generate several controversies on the extreme control that a private company can exercise over the Internet. Piracy Shield has already received widespread criticism, some even coming from AGCOM, the telecommunications regulator that has become the system's main supporter.

The possibility of this system being copied by other countries is very real, with some voices coming from La Liga asking that it also be implemented in Europe. Before this happens, the Computer and Communications Industry Association (CCIA) asked in a letter to the European Commission (via TorrentFreak) to terminate Piracy Shield and verify its legality.

The CCIA is made up of some of the largest internet companies, including Google, Amazon and Cloudflare, which are already among the most affected by Piracy Shield. In fact, one of the main criticisms of the system is that It's too “disgusting” and represents a threat, both to these companies and to the general public.

Piracy Shield works with a blocking system at the DNS (name server) and IP level. Through this system, rights holders can send requests to all operators to block a specific IP address or address range; The process cannot last more than 30 minutes, a measure intended to prevent pirates from finishing watching the match illegally. But this also opens the door to abuse, since IP addresses to be blocked are not verifiedneither by a judge nor by the operator himself, who must only follow the orders of the rights holder; This opens the door to an issue with excessive blocking of legal services and pages.

The CCIA clarified that this warning of excessive blocking is not a hypothesis, but something real that is already happening. To demonstrate this, the organization cites an incident last October, when Google Drive was blocked by Piracy Shield; As a result, the entire service remained inaccessible in Italy for three hours and, up to 12 hours later, 13.% of users were still blocked. Although AGCOM said it was a “simple error”, the fact that such an important vital service could be blocked so easily is proof that Piracy Shield is “too powerful an instrument” to combat the problem of piracy.

As if that wasn't enough, the CCIA claims that Piracy Shield does not have sufficient guarantees or transparency on how it works, which makes correcting errors much more difficult. Another thorny detail concerns the development of the system itself; Piracy Shield was a “gift” from Serie A, the Italian soccer league, to AGCOM, and is one of the few organizations with permission to use the system. This raises the question of whether the system takes into account the interests of all rights holders.

The CCIA calls on AGCOM to, at a minimum, implement verification protocols that avoid these problems and ensure more transparency. But the real “bomb” comes from the request addressed to the European Commission ask the Italian government to immediately stop this system and remove the law that made this possible.

The organization believes that Piracy Shield violates several European laws and should be withdrawn, especially after the latest amendments adding obligations that it says contradict the new Digital Services Act put in place last year. Specifically, one of the amendments requires internet companies to report illegal activity, including copyright violations, or face imprisonment of up to one year. The CCIA believes that this measure goes far beyond the requirements of European law and will affect freedom of expression and innovation online.

Leave a Comment