Instagram, WhatsApp and Facebook have requested access to highly privacy-sensitive aspects of iOS 18. But how did we get there? As you well know, this 2024 was a very intense year between Apple and the European Union. Since the arrival of alternative application stores, the possibility of removing applications as important as Photos or Camera and still pending requests, such as “interoperability” of system applications and third-party companies like Meta.
What is interoperability, the root of the conflict between Apple and Meta
Interoperability is a concept created within the framework of the DMA (European Digital Markets Act). This law requires Apple to provide third-party developers (Instagram, WhatsApp, Facebook, etc.) efficient and free access to the same hardware and software functionalities which are available for Apple via iOS and iPadOS.
This means that developers should have equal access to operating system features, including frameworks, libraries, and other technical features. This avoids “forcing” people to use a specific system application because it has more functions in iOS compared to another application which could be more limited by not having access to certain system functions.
The European Commission has requested that this access to the tools be free and without having to specifically request it. For example, thanks to API calls that allow developers to create with complete freedom. Although this implies an opening of the operating system so great that, at the moment, it is also accepted that developers request access to these specific features and Apple offers a specific solution. It is precisely with these requests that, from Cupertino, they encountered (for them alarming) requests regarding privacy and access to system resources.

The system resources Meta requested access to
Meta's Disturbing Requests
According to Apple's report, Meta made 15 requests to access key technologies in your operating system, including Messaging, AirPlay, CarPlay, and the App Intents framework.
In many cases, Meta seeks to modify functionality in ways that appear completely independent of the actual use of Meta's external devices, such as Meta Smart Glasses and Meta Quest.
The company warns that if it granted all of these requests, Meta apps could access an alarming amount of sensitive data.
If we were to grant all these requests, Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp could access all users' messages and emails, see every phone call made or received, track every app used, scan all their photos, check their files and events calendar, save all your passwords and more. This is data that Apple has chosen not to access in order to provide the greatest possible protection to users.
Apple emphasizes in its report its long history of supporting developer access through over 250,000 APIs, but always with built-in privacy protections, because for them, other companies may not have the same commitment to security and privacy that they have as a company. Additionally, by accessing so much information from iOS, users' information can be moved to other servers, where they can combine, profile, and monetize the customer's private data.

Meta also responds to Apple and calls it anti-competitive
Meta responded by stating that cEvery time Apple is criticized for its anti-competitive behavior, defends itself with privacy arguments that have no basis in reality. However, Meta's credibility on privacy issues has continually been seriously undermined by multiple controversies, such as an Ofcom investigation into Instagram for turning a blind eye to child pornography ads, another $251 million fine for a data breach in 2018 and a report revealing that more than half of scams in the UK involve Meta platforms.

The crucial role of the European Commission
The European Commission seeks to strike a balance between the interoperability required by the DMA and the protection of privacy. The current consultation process sets deadlines specifics for Apple to implement fixes: 90 business days for minor changes and 12 months for larger changes.
Apple has reaffirmed that it will never abandon its fundamental commitment to the privacy and security of its users and is convinced that the European Union will explore how to implement the requirements of interoperability while respecting the protection of user data.
Without a doubt, a difficult conflict to resolve. On the one hand, we understand that Apple does not want to open its operating system “too much” to maintain this exclusivity of functionalities and applications. On the other hand, There is no doubt that the protection and privacy of the user in the Apple ecosystem is one of the highest in the technology industry.
The European Union has established a precise timetable for resolving this conflict between Apple and Meta over interoperability under iOS. The public consultation will be open until January 9, 2025and the Commission will have six months from the start of the procedure (September 2024) to make a final decision. Once notified of this decision, Apple must implement most measures within one month, create a mediation system within three months, and complete technical changes within 90 business days for minor changes to 12 months for major and complex changes.
So the first changes, if they occur, They will arrive mid-year with an additional iOS 18 update. But the biggest changes will come towards the end of the year with iOS 19 installed on all iPhones and iPads. Of course, Meta will have to adapt its applications to the mechanisms or APIs introduced. But for now, we will have to wait to hear Europe's decision. Where will they tip the scales?
Source | European Commission, Apple and Reuters
In Applesfera | How to Turn Your Smartphone into a Dumb Phone and Have the Most Secure iPhone
In Applesfera | Apple Passwords: what it is, what it is for and how secure the new iOS 18 and macOS 15 app is
Table of Contents



