Why do you always press another button for confirmation than with Xbox and PlayStation at Nintendo?

Geralt of Sanctuary

Why do you always press another button for confirmation than with Xbox and PlayStation at Nintendo?

Button, confirmation, Nintendo, PlayStation, press, Xbox

Fortunately, you can do something against the button chaos. (Image: Adobe Stock - Migloga)
Fortunately, you can do something against the button chaos. (Image: Adobe Stock - Migloga)

Fortunately, you can do something against the button chaos. (Image: Adobe Stock – Migloga)

How many times have you pressed the wrong button when you had an unusual controller in your hand? Certainly a few times, right?

The difference between the Gamepads from Nintendo, Xbox and Playstation has cultural backgrounds.

Provided getting used to

Why are we suppressing each other? The reason is simple: At Nintendo, the confirmation button is on the right side of the buttons. At PlayStation and Xbox, it is confirmed below. So muscle memory plays a prank after the change.

So the buttons are arranged in detail:

Nintendo consoles

  • Confirmation: A-button (right)
  • Demolition: B-button (below)

PlayStation und Xbox

  • Confirmation: X button (below) at PlayStation, A-button (below) at Xbox
  • Demolition: O-button (right) at Playstation, B-button (right) at Xbox

But why are the buttons not standardized?

Japan does it differently

The answer lies in the cultural differences between Japan and the West. In Japan, the home of Nintendo and Sony, the cross traditionally has a different meaning than with us:

  • In Japan the circle means traditional And or Correct
  • The cross, however, stands for No or Incorrect

Teiyu Goto, the designer of the Playstation controller, thought the following how Cnet reported:

  • Cross should No mean
  • Circle was for And scheduled
  • Triangle symbolized perspective/direction
  • Quadrat stood for menus/documents

In Japan, the button was to confirm on the right, regardless of whether the PlayStation or the A button at Nintendo.

The western interpretation

Interestingly, the logic in western markets was reversed. Here we tend to connect the X symbol to Select/tickduring the circle as Stop or cancel could be interpreted (via JapanConsultingOffice).

At least that may have been the thought of the Sony responsible. Because you could argue just as well that the cross is to be interpreted as a negative or as a lock.

Only stayed in Japan: In Japanese PlayStation games, the circle was long to confirm and the cross used for breaking off-until then the PS5 came and Sony decided to change the layout in Japan.

In the meantime, the Playstation is also confirmed with a cross in Japan.

Nintendo has retained its button arrangement across all consoles generations. From Super Nintendo to Switch: A on the right, B below.

This consistency ensures a uniform feeling within the Nintendo cosmos. But makes the change to other systems all the more confusing.

What about Xbox? We can only assume why Xbox has decided to confirm on the lower button. However, since the first Xbox only appeared years after the first Playstation, Microsoft may have been based on the example of the PlayStation.

Consoles 2025: Will Switch 2 become the last successful console?
Consoles 2025: Will Switch 2 become the last successful console?


Start video


56:00


Consoles 2025: Will Switch 2 become the last successful console?

Adaptation options for frustrated players

The good news: modern consoles offer solutions for this problem. This is how it works:

  • Nintendo: Settings → Controller and sensors → Change button allocation
  • PlayStation: Settings → Accessibility → Controller → Custom key assignment
  • Xbox: Xbox accessories-App download and open → Select controller → presses on configure and then Keying

So you no longer have to get used to it if you switch between different systems – provided you take the time for the configuration.

What do you all mean? Have you already got used to the different layouts or are you still crushing yourself regularly? Write it to us in the comments!

Leave a Comment